You May Like
Peanuts Multi-Point Halloween Pencils 4-Pack New
$6.99
View Details
Bag Of 40 Brand New Halloween Pencils Spider Witches Candy Corn Black Cat & More
$5.95
View Details
27 Halloween Unsharpened Pencils Trick or Treat Pumpkins Ghosts, Spider Webs New
$5.00
View Details
xutengy 72Pcs Halloween Pencils Stationery Party Favors Set， Halloween Themed...
$13.48
View Details
Halloween Pencil, Character Crazy Head Pencil Eco Tandarin Tree Pencils Wood
$15.00
View Details
Vintage 1978 Garfield Halloween Trick or Treat Pencils 70s Lot Of 13
$10.50
View Details
NOS VTG 90's Lot of Halloween Pencils - Party Favors
$11.95
View Details
Vintage 1992 PENTECH Pack of 15 Halloween Pencils NEW Package SEALED Made in USA
$9.99
View Details
VTG Lisa Frank Halloween Pencils 1989 NEW Old Stock 8 Pack Skull Bat Cat 1980's
$14.99
View Details
3 Halloween Pencils Little Knitmares / Crazy Head Clown/ Chucky Boy / Red Devil
$24.00
View Details
Vintage 1990's Halloween Pencils Set of 12 Wal Mart #12262 Sealed in Package
$19.99
View Details
Rare Lisa Frank 90 Halloween Pencils Set Eraser Toppers Stickers Stencils NEW
$149.99
View Details
Halloween Pencils 40 Pencils Total Great For Trick-Or-Treat
$7.25
View Details
12 Count Halloween pencils Spiders Pumpkins With Erasers Unsharpened real wood
$2.50
View Details
PEANUTS SNOOPY HALLOWEEN PENCILS- MIXED LOT OF 12 *NEW*
$12.50
View Details
Halloween Pencils Jack-O-Lantern Skull Ghost Pumpkin Lot Of 11 Pencils Unused
$8.97
View Details
Lot of 9 Vtg HALLOWEEN & Moonbeam Wood Pencils-Unused
$7.99
View Details
Vintage Lisa Frank Halloween 2 Pencils With Toppers and Erasers
$7.99
View Details
Vintage 90s Pencils Halloween (17 USA) & (1) Berol Party Favors NEW NOS
$10.00
View Details
Sealed Vintage Lisa Frank Halloween Pencils
$23.00
View Details
Happy Halloween Wooden Pencils Set of 12 Ghosts Pumpkins Black Orange White New
$12.14
View Details
VTG HALLOWEEN BIG FAT PENCILS 4CT 15" WITH SHARPNER (BOO, SKELETONS, SPIDERS, WI
$7.97
View Details
16 Halloween Pencils Classroom Reward Party Favor Trick-or-Treat Teacher Supply
$7.99
View Details
Target Halloween Pencils Erasers Pumpkin Ghost Party Favor Vintage Set
$10.80
View Details
Little Knitmares Crazy Head Halloween Eco Tandarin Tree Pencils
$15.00
View Details
436 Pcs 24 Pack Assorted Halloween Stationery Set Halloween Party Favors for ...
$28.21
View Details
Halloween Table Decoration Pencil Storage Organizer Skull Decorative Figurine
$12.18
View Details
NEW Pkg 10 Vintage Halloween Pencils 1990s Trick or Treat Ghosts, Bats, Pumpkins
$15.00
View Details
![Halloween Pencil, 48-Pack [Multiple Colors]](https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/NhIAAOSwXclnMITb/s-l600.webp)
Halloween Pencil, 48-Pack [Multiple Colors]
$24.00
View Details
VINTAGE 1990s Russ Trolls Happy Halloween Pencil w/ Topper
$9.99
View Details
Lot 16 Vtg Halloween Pencils Unsharpened 1990s Pentech 1978 Garfield Ghosts Bats
$14.00
View Details
The Wicked Witch Crazy Head Rustic Wood Pencil Halloween Novelty Thailand
$7.50
View Details
Vintage Lisa Frank Halloween Pencils With Erasers Lot Of 28 Unused
$49.95
View Details
Vintage Lot of 22 Happy Halloween Pencils with Toppers Erasers New, Unused
$16.87
View Details
Vintage Happy Halloween lead pencil 1989 Noteworthy Bats Pumpkin Design
$10.98
View Details
VINTAGE NEW LISA FRANK HALLOWEEN PARTY FAVORS PACK OF 15 SCARY HALLOWEEN PENCILS
$19.95
View Details
Vintage Halloween Pencils 12 Count Sealed Package
$8.97
View Details
Vintage Lisa Frank Scary Pencils - Halloween Pencils - New Sealed! Pack Of 15
$19.96
View Details
VINTAGE 90'S LISA FRANK HALLOWEEN BIG ERASER PENCIL UNSHARPENED Jack O Lantern
$9.00
View Details
Halloween Pumpkin Pencils - 24 Pc. Jack o'Lanterns Party Favors Treasure Box
$8.49
View Details
Halloween Pencils Set of 12 Pumpkins Candy Corn Ghosts Skulls
$6.95
View Details
WICKED WITCH & BLACK CAT Crazy Head WOOD PENCIL Set Halloween Novelty
$9.99
View Details
2 Vintage Lisa Frank Halloween Bat Pencils Unsharpened
$14.00
View Details
VERY HARD TO FIND McDonald's Happy Halloween Pencil - BRAND NEW!!
$1.00
View Details
4 VIntage DIG #2 HB Unsharpened Halloween Pencils W/ Erasers Cat Bat Pumpkin
$9.89
View Details
HALLOWEEN 3 Pencils w/ Pumpkin Erasers & Jack-O-Lantern Notepad w/ Pen NEW
$4.20
View Details
Vintage 1978 Garfield 15 Halloween Trick or Treat Orange Pencils Rare
$15.99
View Details
VTG ERASERS LOT He-Man Garfield Diener Hearts Dino Kittens Car Halloween 80s
$16.00
View Details
16 Vintage Novelty Holiday Pencils Unsharpened Hanna Barbera, Disney Halloween
$7.00
View Details
Sanford Bundle of 30+ Novelty Halloween Pencils With Toppers. U.S.A. NOS Sealed!
$25.00
View Details
30 PCS Wood Halloween Pencil Child Writing Assorted Pattern Pencils
$10.99
View Details
HALLOWEEN SPOOKY PENCILS - DECORATED WITH GHOSTS, TOMBSTONES, BLACK CATS, BATS !
$10.50
View Details
Halloween Pencils 12 Pack Open Unused Kid Vampire Kid Witch Ghost Pumpkin VTG
$9.93
View Details
Vintage Halloween Orange and Black Swirl Witch Oversized Pencil 12 1/4"
$12.00
View Details
Vintage Lisa Frank Ghoulish Halloween Pencils with Erasers Lot of 8
$17.95
View Details
Halloween SKULL Erasers Pencil Top Toppers Party Favors Trick or Treat 24 ct NEW
$10.95
View Details
Vintage 90's Lisa Frank Halloween Pencil W/ Frankenstein Eraser Topper New
$12.00
View Details
Halloween Emoji Pencils - 24 Piece - Party Favors Treasure Box ~ Wood
$8.49
View Details
Lot of 13 Unused Garfield Halloween Trick or Treat Pencils USA 1978 Orange
$13.99
View Details
Vintage Halloween Themed Pencils-Sharpened-Used-Jack O Latern-Bats-Ghosts-Skulls
$8.99
View Details
VTG Little Knitmares Crazy Head Halloween Eyeball Piercing Horror Monster Pencil
$9.95
View Details
Vintage 90s Lot Of 55 Wood Pencils Kids Theme Lisa Frank Pokemon Halloween COOL
$16.97
View Details
Vintage Lisa Frank Halloween Pencils - Lot Of 8 Cats, Halloween,
$11.89
View Details
Vintage 90s Lisa Frank Halloween Pencil With Eraser Boo Unused
$4.95
View Details
Vtg Lot PENCILS w/ TOPPERS Halloween Dialers Keys PVC Rubber Wooden Shoe
$14.99
View Details
Premiere 3D Halloween Pencil Erasers 5 Count Skulls Pumpkin Bat Owl New
$1.99
View Details
Vtg Frankenstein Halloween Hand Painted Resin Pencil Figure 10" Artmark Box NOS
$14.95
View Details
Halloween Pencils Broom Witch Wizard Wand Set Of 2 Pencils FREE SHIPPING
$8.89
View Details
18 Piece Halloween Eraser Pencil Topper Monster Themed Erasers Rare Discontinued
$5.00
View Details
Vintage Novelty Halloween Pencils 6 Toppers Witch Ghost Frankenstein
$8.49
View Details
Little Knitmares~Chucky Boy Halloween Handcrafted Pencil 🎃 Natural Wooden NEW
$12.99
View Details
VTG HALLOWEEN PENCILS 15CT JOL & FRANKENSTEIN BLACK & ORANGE EMPIRE NOS
$11.91
View Details
NIB PEANUTS Halloween PENCIL SET Snoopy Charlie Brown Vintage Great Pumpkin
$15.19
View Details
Halloween Novelty Pencils Lot of 7 - Jack O Lantern Black Cat Bat
$8.95
View Details
Vintage Empire Halloween Pencils Opened 15-Pack & Bonus!
$14.00
View Details
RARE 1990s Vintage Lisa Frank Halloween Christmas Holiday Unsharpened Pencils
$8.49
View Details
NEW Sealed 1998 Pentech Halloween 12 Pencils Ghosts Pumpkins Witch Kmart Vtg
$14.99
View Details
Crazy Head Pirate Wood Pencil Skeleton Skull Spooky Halloween
$4.24
View Details
Vintage NIB PEANUTS Halloween Pencils Snoopy Charlie Brown THE GREAT PUMPKIN
$8.95
View Details
Crazy Head 8.75” Wood Pencil Girl Woman with Glasses Halloween
$10.00
View Details
Red Punk Man Miss Blue Hair CRAZY HEAD Wood Pencil Halloween Novelty Thailand 2
$12.99
View Details
Two (2) Different Vintage 1989 Noteworthy Halloween Mechanical Pencils
$9.98
View Details
Spooky Village 12 count Halloween Pencils Sealed NEW in package
$2.00
View Details
Vintage Scooby Doo Pencil Lot, Halloween, Smiley Face, Kittens,90s
$24.99
View Details
THE WICKED WITCH Crazy Head WOOD PENCIL Halloween Novelty
$9.99
View Details
Halloween Pencils Empire Berol Made in USA 15 ct
$14.99
View Details
Vintage GARFIELD Halloween Pencils 14pcs UNOPENED SEALED #14
$14.99
View Details
way to celebrate 12 count halloween pencils school party gifts goody bags kids
$7.99
View Details
Skull Pencil Topper Eraser stackers set of 2 HALLOWEEN
$9.99
View Details
Lot of 2 12 packs= 24 HALLOWEEN PENCILS Classroom Size Favors Goodie Bag fillr
$8.29
View Details
16 Halloween Pencils Classroom Reward Party Favor Trick-or-Treat Teacher Supply
$7.99
View Details
